They really shouldn't have said that this was taking place in the Prime Universe, but who knows, maybe they'll make it pay off interestingly. The exceptions are Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, where Commander Benjamin Sisko (Avery Brooks) wasn't promoted to Captain . And yeah, agree with Dom: zero suspense. This is also why I brought up "Errand of Mercy" in an earlier post. This will give you half the blueprints you need to build the Botany Bay. Wow, that was terrible. Exocomp Consumables enable players to obtain and activate powerful, temporary Galaxy, Station and Combat boosts. Its laughable that you think your actions here on Earth will affect the behavior of the Sun. Lorca and his men seek out Paul Stamets and use his bioweapon to start killing the Emperor's crew. Of course, it could be Culber but MU Lorca is far more devious and I'd expect this from him. Forget about how that humongous lithium-ion battery was developed, what its useful lifespan is and what will happen to it once its finally depleted. As for the rest of the crew, remember one of the first scenes on board Discovery was Rekah Sharma conspiring to let someone beat up an unarmed prisoner. You hand him the $40. Since everything before his radically unveiled true self was merely an act, most of his interactions from the first half of the season represent an infuriatingly pointless web of lies. So even if I will miss Isaacs, there's a definite upside to having Lorca out of the picture. "What's Past Is Prologue," then, finally puts Lorca front and centre as the key villain - despite having played it since first appearing in the Prime universe via transporter malfunction. So, I thought about it some more and I have to emphasize my point - this was awesome but not good. All she does is ripping some glowing cables out of a wall yeah, well, of course people don't believe that she hacked anything, because there was neither time (the conversation starts immediatly after) and she didn't actually do anything conducive to her aim Bang-on review, Jammer. What continues to irk me is that the mirror universe arc began so promisingly by placing Discovery at the scene of a battle near Organia ("Despite Yourself"). I thought all the acting was superb. Because of the interesting moral, ethical and philosophical questions raised. The Gold Edition of Star Trek: Starfleet Command is an enhanced re-release which comes patched to version 1.03, and includes all the missions which were previously downloadable from the official website (3 for the Federation, 3 for the Klingons . [Quote Peter G:] I'd like to be able to make some grand-sweeping statement like "the moral fiber of this show is completely degenerate" but I think that would be missing the point. Official Subreddit for all things Star Trek: Fleet Command, the newest MMORPG by Scopely. Star Trek is supposed to focus on moral and ethical issues. Ill keep grinding and it will resolve itself soon I am sure. Saru though is so complex, he has a lot of strange faults but mostly when it gets important he is is extremely clear and well spoken. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. I was on the edge of my seat for most of this one. Lorca abused our idealism. Saru made a fantastic speech. I liked the ending scenes of Stamets navigating the network as well. Haunting. Discovery seems like it has that vibe, going from the Klingon war to the MU, etc. Saru was willing to blow up the Charon with Murca and everyone else on board just on the word of mutineer Burnham whom he intensely disliked earlier in the season, whom he tried to kill not that long ago, and whom he now, out of the blue, calls "friend"? At one point he seems to talk about shows like Discovery. Im stuck here as well. TNG was successful. This is a really disappointing conclusion to the longest of this season's long cons. Here's how every Captain gained command of a starship throughout the Star Trek TV series and movies. honestly, for all the high octane drama drama Discovery is putting out, a lot of these comments are way more melodramatic than the actual show. It's nice that we'll continue having Michell Yeoh with us, but I'd expect this character to have a Plan B. I was waiting for the Defiant to be found. Nope) My only hope for the solution of those inconsistancies is for it to be revealed that we are, in fact in an alternate Universe. Watching last night's episode of Star Trek: Discovery, "What's Past is Prologue," I couldn't help but think about another Trek episodeThe Next Generation's "The Measure of a Man . Battle Pass 1 . Here we go, the good, the bad, and the Discovery. Mindless slaughter of characters. I just thought of something else. This is a pattern type cookie set by Google Analytics, where the pattern element on the name contains the unique identity number of the account or website it relates to. By Star Trek | 10 August 2021 Commanders, We are happy to announce Scopely Account - a unified new way to login to not only Star Trek Fleet Command, but all Scopely games! The crew convey the importance of bringing down the containment field around the energy orb powering the palace ship. Explore strange new worlds, seek out new life and new civilizations, boldly go where no one has gone before! Saru stands in a room full of recurring players and extras (some who actually get to have multiple spoken lines! The pilot and ep2 were just a prologue for what I thought was the real show; with Lorca a fake, it looks like this whole season was just a prologue for whatever the hell is the actual "real show" that this will become when they beat back the Klingons, and I'm not sure anymore what that will be. They even have him chalk up his random and unlikely universe-crossing and subsequently successful plan as "destiny," making him into a self-professed fate-chosen megalomaniac, which comes across as a scripted way of admitting the plot was so hopelessly contrived that it must be acknowledged as being guided from a higher plane. There were also some nice, rising level of respect moments between Stamets and Tilly IMO this is the series' first 4-star episode! Secondly, while I recognize that Discovery has developed into a well-executed action series - I never liked "action Trek" much myself. discovery is cbs attempt to eliminate TOS well i prefer to see TOS than this sh* t. @Chrome, before Discovery, I would have also thought Starfleet officers wouldnt attempt mutiny in order to launch a preemptive attack against the Klingons, wouldnt condone abuse of prisoners, etc. Thanks again! :). Someone else did mention that earlier, that the spore may be Lorca, and god I hope not. There's no consideration for what any broader message might be, and so any message one can draw from the show is going to be largely accidental rather than by design. However those episodes where pretty straight forward plot wise where as this episode of DSC has lots of twists and turns. I've watched for years; you let alien races spill over the borders, flourish in our backyard, then have the gall to incite rebellion. That Klingons are stand-ins for Trump supporters? Everything seems to be coming together for Star Trek: Discovery plot-wise as we head into the final two episodes of the season, with the Mirror Universe story and Lorca's arc satisfyingly (if. If I remember right, didnt TNG try to avoid any references to TOS in the early seasons, to make it's own mark and avoid being seen to ride on the success of the original crew (besides McCoy in Encounter at Farpoint and the The Naked Now)? The emperor, too, is thinking back to her relationship with the mirror Burnham, when Commander Burnham finds her. My excitement for the next episode dropped about 50% from where it's been. Action packed episode, but lots more suspension of disbelief required. In Saru we find a leader who acknowledges his fear and steps beyond it to do what's right. At least then I can think about what makes for good TV. The spore network can be manipulated by technology. Maybe it's just that the show didn't do enough to show the general unease amongst the crew members to sell us on the fact that it was the captain, not the ship, that was suspicious. The show doesn't really do anything with that. Or to put it another way, its now considered heresy not to bow at the altar of global warming. The more I look at this season, the more I think the whole thing must be a prologue to a more normalized second season, because this level of crazy just can't be sustained. I thought he was fascinating, and then they just made him some moustache twirling comic book villain in the final episode. Did the MU resistance cell get accidentally transported to the Prime Universe? The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary". Always has, always will. Gamers can put their strategic and tactical abilities to the test in this thrilling game, Star Trek Fleet Command (STFC). I watched this episode a few days ago, and have finished the season today. Georgiou eventually defeats Lorca by stabbing him through the heart with her sword, before kicking him through a force field out into space to be vaporized in the ship's mycelial sun. First step: download the emulator and install it. Are they going to have daily Kelpian barbecues in every Terran kindergarten? Gamers can put their strategic abilities to the test in this thrilling mobile game, Star Trek Fleet Command. First, RIP Lorca. Tags: Main Storyline Missions. And kudos to Jammer for allowing such a free-flowing and sometimes heated discussion on his site. When Gene Coon was pushing his politics, utopianism, and even corny Christianity, you believed it. This cookie is set by the Cookie Consent solution. ( TOS: " The City on the Edge of Forever ", ENT: " Storm Front ") Contents 1 Early usage DS9 wasn't trying to depict a realistic war, it was trying to get viewers to question if and when the ends really do justify the means. The finest a captain could ever hope to command. Also, are you also asserting that magnetic pole flipping has no climatological efgect? ", "Hello, Philippa. Used to track the information of the embedded YouTube videos on a website. I did figure it out. Discovery has shown itself to be a compulsively watchable nuts-and-bolts plot-moving vehicle. If you love Discovery, that's great - the best way to convince others and share your enthusiasm for the show is to tell us (passionately and sincerely) why you think it's great and what you like about each week's episode (maybe that will help more people see the good in it), instead of just berating anyone who has the temerity to say otherwise. Have to agree with others about Lorca. Discovery receives a message from the Charon and drops out of warp, then receives a hail from Lorca. Your password must include at least 8 characters with a combination of upper/lower case, number and symbol. Spot-on review Jammer, down to the smallest details. The writers should be commended for not prolonging this needlessly. Suddenly, the crew of the Discovery would be faced with a radically different universe where there is no war with the Klingons, and where the Klingons look just like humans. "Nah". In the real world, such an event would lead to a massive civil war as pretenders tried to become the new emperor or carve up the Empire into bite sized pieces, which would then be conquered by others. There's a difference in that we don't actually see the character traits you mention, we have to infer them and fill in the blanks retrospectively. The Terrans need a leader who will preserve our way of life, our race. Enter the email address associated with your account and we'll send you a link to reset your password. But the show is called "Star Trek" after all. Hit mobile game Star Trek Fleet Command is about to expand into every corner of the science-fiction franchise's many shows, with characters, story lines and ships from the all. Lorca and his men seek out Paul Stamets and use his bioweapon to start killing the Emperor's crew. The cookie is used to calculate visitor, session, campaign data and keep track of site usage for the site's analytics report. In 2370, a seven-year-old named Paul Menegay . I was told to "stop watching" by someone in The Orville comments despite the fact I positively reviewed about half the episodes, just because my reviewers for the other episodes that I didn't like were too critical for that person's taste. In the throne room aboard the Charon, Landry reports to Lorca that the emperor's crew has either been killed or joined their movement. . It's not just that they ruined Lorca's character arc by making him a generic Evil Empire man; it's that it was so obvious how to fix it! It's not crazy to expect it to look and feel and smell and sound like "Star Trek." Mining resources. I absolutely loved the scene where Discovery's crew brainstorms together and it ends with Saru's speech to the crew. It's one of the reasons why the TNG movies are so meh to me. No, just no. As Zack Handlen commented, the long-planned "twist" plays exactly like a last-minute write-out of the kind that writers are forced to do when actors suddenly become unavailable. And today will be her maiden voyage. Choose your own path and discover mysteries only you can solve as you boldly go where no one has gone before! So yes, I liked this episode - I have also already forgotten most of it, I was most excited for the ending and the crew interactions. I pose that question because we've always had a Malankovitch cycle, but Earth went through hundreds of millions of years without Ice Ages. Saru rallies the senior officers, indicating he does not sense death in their future and that they will defeat this "no-win scenario.". It's a waste of a fine actor in Jason Isaacs, who now leaves the series because the events of this episode render his character dead and disintegrated barring some other insane twist that reveals the Prime Universe Lorca somehow survived the destruction of the Buran. Aboard Discovery, the crew discuss options to destroy the energy orb, but the only option seems as though it will also result in the Discovery's destruction. I don't think these revelations made Lorca a simplistic character. Go To Krenim Research Facility. I have always come back to episodes of TNG, DS9 and Voyager. This was because he was interested in showing them finally working as a family-like team, having been united by Saru's speech. She is ours. The fact that Lorca commanded the Buran was a big hint that he was from the MU. I dont think that this is generally done maliciously but nevertheless its deeply problematic. Players are invited to immerse themselves in a fictional space world in this role-playing mobile game, Star Trek Fleet Command (STFC). Building up to an explosive final act. I think I don't have to get nitpicky, that has been done already I think. Instead, he made Star Wars, was allowed to do his own thing, and the rest is history. I'd like to see a little more of Lorca's story fleshed out in the following episodes. And the writers surprise here with a visceral hour that burns through the rest of the Mirror Universe arc at an almost stunningly furious pace, leaving the last two episodes of the season to deal with other business. ", "Believe in destiny now, Mr. She is ours. (Including an excellent post by juss100, which I didn't mention specificially before.) The battleship parts can be used to upgrade your fleet and a relocation token can change your bases location. The Earth did that all by itself.". Would at least explain her mary sue status. Truth be told, that was probably more my approach when I was younger. DSC is selling the action-adventure side of Star Trek better than any of its progenitors, and the furious storytelling pace always keeps me interested. I think what you describe can be found in the comment section of an episode like Spock's Brain. I think I've just become a bit more wary during the past decade given the way corporations use and misuse franchises by deviating so far from the original spirit and values. Anyone see the preview? Lorca plans to move forward with a coup against the Emperor, propelling Burnham to make a quick decision to save not only herself, but the U.S.S. It plays like a Marvel Comic Book movie, content to distract with infodumps, quips, twists and constant violence. Unofficial reddit community for Star Trek Fleet Command. I may not have all the answers; however, I do know that I am surrounded by a team I trust. By the way (and apologies for the multiple postings; I keep thinking of more things to say, which is a good thing, I suppose), what was up with Murca's "fate brought me here" spiel? They shared two fucking scenes in the pilot, one in the desert and one on the bridge. I really hoped you were dead." And I just can't get over how mad *this* episode makes me. Lazy writing that reaches only for the most obvious, only the most cliche at all times. Next, we will install the Star Trek Fleet Command game. ", "I think it's made crystal clear in this series, beyond any possibility of doubt, that each Alpha Quadrant race had exactly two choices: join the Dominion as their servants, or die.". Not only is it consistent with what we know about MU characters from "Mirror, Mirror" and "In a Mirror, Darkly" but I suspect it will make the first half of this season more interesting on rewatch. Burnham promises to take down the containment field. HOWEVER with a capital everything this episode plays out pretty much the worst-case scenario regarding "Captain" Lorca, reducing him to a brutal, evil, pointless supervillain that retroactively destroys what was once an intriguing and potentially complicated character. Shannon, you've clearly got a naughty list of commenters that you don't like. You need to look very hard to find terms like 'frustrating', 'annoyed me to hell', 'brainless' or 'fucking awful'. What do I get? 2 weeks ago Page transparency See all Facebook is showing information to help you better understand the purpose of a Page. Click locate it should take you to the location you need to go. > What STD did to Captain Lorca is consistent with SJW agenda of the series: white. Still, there's so many pieces missing from his story, and it was a little convenient how Stamets very neatly connected the dots in a manner of seconds. @Peter, fair enough about the analogy. ", "We would've helped you get home if you had asked! Lorca is the man who would kill Georgiou and take over as the head of an equally if not more oppressive and brutal empire, and has been lying to Burnham for the previous 10 episodes. If the MU was supposed to be 21st century America, what did it say about 21st century America? Similar in structure to West World. But, maybe when the ISS Charon blew up, so did the anti alien xenophobia? No one else left is particularly compelling, especially Burnham (and the show desperately wants us to adore her). Therefore, your crew members must be optimised, upgraded and correctly chosen according to the situation and the ship used! I just dont find the mirror universe fun in Discovery. Was reading a book by the philosopher Zizek. The episode raises profound ethical questions that wouldn't be possible in a show like 24, where violence and Jack Bauer moral ambiguity are normalized. When I hit locate it takes me to a system called Ester which is like a Warp 50 system but the mission is supposed to be done when I'm level 7? @ Jay - I completely agree with you. By Dragonbane November 11th, 2022 No Comments. New items (Exocomp Consumables) that can be used to boost Galaxy, Station and Combat activities. the bad guys were Really Bad and Evil. Part of my concern is that the modern trend to set stories inside existing fictional universes is stifling the creation of new, possibly better fictional universes. Are we supposed to take any story implications from that, or is that the writer's way of saying "yes, we know that Murca didn't have a plan and it took all the pieces to fall just right for him to have the opportunity to return to the MU, so don't think about it anymore, because neither will we, since we want to spend our last episode with Murca fighting, not figuring out his plans and motivations"? Landry attempts to capture her while Lorca is distracting her, only to find Burnham had rerouted the communications feed masking her location. Except the way it actually played out, was it seemed like a cursory plot twist thrown in to make it sound epic, but lacking any emotional or intellectual impact. I'd hoped perhaps that MU Lorca might have noble motives within his own universe, but no, it turns out that the Empire just isn't quite racist enough for him. By clicking Accept you consent to the use of all cookies. The side quests, on the other hand, serve as a bonus and allow you to gain levels faster. Great characterization, very believable. Commanders, With 2022 coming to a close we're already prepping to boldly go into 2023. The Star Trek Fleet Command offers many ways to tackle these dangers, but learning how to use them can take quite a long time. [April Fools] By Star Trek | 1 April 2021. Disappointing. How long will mirror-Georgiou remain on the show, and what will her role be? Oh no! People always write that DIS isnt trek. The other half can be purchased from the Augment Faction Store at 6/day if you are OPs 18+. They asked to travel to Valance (lvl 28), which needs Warp 24 ship. Michael Burnham is not to be touched. Basically it takes buzzwords from quantum and twists them into meaning unscientific things. But as a wrap-up to Lorca's mysterious character arc, it feels like an act of arson against much of the season. I was excited about Discovery because the writers kept talking about how Trek could be a powerful political allegory for our troubled times, but it really hasn't engaged in any meaningful way. @Peter G.: "Just to clarify (not that I'm the world's authority), there is no basis whatsoever for (a) suspecting there to be a fungus/spore based network in space - not even a fringe theory. Fictional universes have much clearer identities now. More importantly, the episode doesn't do anything to develop those themes. Fighting Hostiles. "this episode plays out pretty much the worst-case scenario regarding "Captain" Lorca". Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features. "What's Past Is Prologue" was the 13th episode of Star Trek: Discovery in the show's first season, first aired 28 January 2018. At the very least, it keeps Michelle Yeoh on the series for a while longer, which I can't complain about. @Nolan: I fully agree with you. Basically, you go into it the first time not knowing where it will go. I'll never get there! ", ability; agony booth; Alpha Quadrant; ambush; answer; battalion; Battle of the Binary Stars; bioweapon; black alert; border; brig; Buran, ISS; carrier address; celestial pattern; Charon, ISS; clearing; containment field; coup d'tat; death; emergency transport; emperor; energy dispersal; flash grenade; forest; Georgiou, Philippa; hack; Harlak; hypergravity; idealism; ion storm; leader; life sign; lord; magnetic field; maiden voyage; mirror universe; multiverse; mycelial energy; mycelial network; mycelial shockwave; mycelial spore; mycelium; nanometer; noose; no-win scenario; order; parallel universe; pathway; photon torpedo; physics; pillow talk; poetic justice; poetry; poison; Priors World; race; rebellion; revolution; sanctuary; senior officer; Starbase 46; subatomic analysis; super-mycelial reactor; superstructure; sword; terahertz; throne room; torture; transporter signature; United Federation of Planets; vaporize setting, Acamar; Carraya; Celes; Paulson Nebula; Starbase 157. Privacy Policy. I honestly enjoy reading reviews of this show more than I do watching it. Star Trek: Discovery "What's Past Is Prologue" Air date: 1/28/2018 Written by Ted Sullivan Directed by Olatunde Osunsanmi. Long, cringeworthy speeches with a shoehorned Trump reference. This felt like Star Wars meets The Matrix meets Star Trek 2009. Lorca leads from a place of fear, and the speeches he makes while overthrowing Georgiou underline the Terran Empire's totalitarian worldview. And before any comparison to Q pops up: Q is a metaphor, above all else, a plot device, not a science gadget. I'm only watching Discovery now on the heels of having finished ST: Picard. Dragonbane November 11, 2022. I'll try to raise a few points others didn't raise: "This is beyond the Force, which doesn't allow for interstellar travel", @Plain Simple: "The action scenes were very well done. She'll show us how winning wars is done! Saru full time, awesome! And he's going to make the Empire glorious again compared to what? Spore drive is clearly science fantasy realm. It seems like the episode is trying to get viewers worried that the Federation might lose. The purpose of the cookie is to determine if the user's browser supports cookies. Having a mustache-twirling villain spout racist nonsense isn't particularly insightful or interesting because it tells us nothing we don't already know about evil. It doesn't matter what we do here. Mindless action. These cookies ensure basic functionalities and security features of the website, anonymously. It's a shame to lose Isaac, to lose an interestign character, that the things that made his character interesting all boiled down to "Mirror Universe evulz". ago I can't archive it. This is not arson, but the foundational purpose of the entire character and arc. This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate the website. You can find your available missions on the left-hand side of the screen. Two episodes left - here we go @KT: "I disagree. Instead, build suspense by getting us to care about characters and then making us wonder about their fates. Support it by buying Jammer a coffee. Fortunately, there is a possible solution to complete the quest. This was a fine, exciting conclusion to the Mirror Universe arc. That's what Starfleet is. Look for Star Trek Fleet Command in the search bar at the top right corner. What matters most is imagery & symbolismform over substance. The mission can also be seen in the series, where Lorca plans to move forward with a coup against the Emperor, propelling Burnham to make a quick decision to not only save herself, but the U.S.S Discovery too. This is a deeply charismatic, utterly amoral, extremely proficient ACTOR (I mean Lorca, not Isaacs) - something like, as I said, Iago, or maybe Richard III. This site is for all opinions, positive and negative. The technobabble plot solution is pretty standard Trekkian fare except for the unnecessary upping of the ante that alleges the destruction of the mycelium network would cause "all life as we know it" in all universes to end if the Charon is allowed to continue using their power source that draws from it. What I am invested in, however, is freedom of speech and opinion, and Ive noticed a worrying trend from people that somewhat mirrors the experiences I had talking about TV on internet forums around ten years ago and thats subtle, nuanced attempts to silence people who dont like it, but wish to discuss their disapproval or disappointment. Throwing a bunch of villains on the screen doesn't really shed any light into the nature of evil or societal ills. Discovery. This is it for me, On Burnham saving MGeorgiou: It was clearly an emotional, impulsive decision. Star Trek Fleet Command, the popular mobile strategy game, is making the jump to PC. Some of them are not bad, it's just that they do not offer a lot below the level of action and suspense. Discovery basically offers Saturday Morning Cartoon level writing. There's usually a lot of things to keep track of . Im stuck on this mission and cannot figure out where to go next. #2. Burnham accesses the Charon's communications system to contact the Discovery, warning them that Lorca is in fact from the mirror universe. And they even grew to like and admire him. We have a duty to perform, and we will not accept a no-win scenario. Weak and Powerless. It seems this mission, What's Past is Prologue, is not supposed to be a long-distance Warp 40 mission. The last thing climate cultists want is reasonable debate with facts.